A Kansas injunction and new South Carolina and Tennessee laws show how families are using the ADA to win access to ABA in schools during the school day.
Key Takeaways
- A court reopened the classroom door: A federal judge in August barred a Kansas district from enforcing its ban on outside ABA therapists against two students, finding its objections unsupported by caselaw.
- Disability law is the new route: Advocates frame a privately funded therapist as an ADA accommodation, a claim that can reach federal court quickly, though federal appeals courts disagree on when families must first exhaust special education appeals.
- Statehouses are filling in the details: South Carolina and Tennessee enacted school-access laws in 2026, Colorado has required district policies since 2023, and bills are pending in Michigan and Massachusetts.
- Implementation comes next: South Carolina districts have until July 2027 to adopt policies, and attendees said parents are already hearing different answers from district to district.
For the 2024 to 2025 school year, two girls with autism in Manhattan, Kansas, went to class with ABA therapists from a private provider, Ad Astra MHK, working alongside them. The families’ private insurance covered the therapy. Teachers and principals, according to a later federal court order, reported that the therapists’ presence “was helpful and did not interfere with learning activities.”
Then, in the summer of 2025, the Manhattan-Ogden school district ended private ABA in schools across the district. Its new Policy KM, in the court’s words, prohibited “ABA therapy in all classrooms.” One girl moved to a parochial school. The other was homeschooled. Both, according to the order, lost ground they had gained.
Their parents, Kevin and Pamela Steinmetz and Amanda and Blake Gray, sued the district in April 2026 under Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act and Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act. On Aug. 4, U.S. District Judge Anthony J. Powell granted a preliminary injunction barring the district from enforcing the policy against the two students and their therapists.
The case came up in late October in Charleston, S.C., during the Legal Update session at the 20th Autism Law Summit. Dan Unumb, President of the Autism Legal Resource Center, said he had connected Kevin Steinmetz with pro bono attorneys and worked with them on the case. He called the ruling “just a good case for parents and providers to be able to point to.”
It lands as several states write the same idea into statute. The argument, in both the courtroom and the statehouse, treats a privately funded therapist in a classroom as a disability accommodation, which moves the dispute out of special education law, and its long argument over educational versus medical necessity for ABA, and into civil rights law.
Why ABA Advocates Treat the Classroom as a Treatment Setting
Unumb’s case for school access starts with the therapy itself. ABA works on the relationship between behavior and environment, and he pointed to CASP’s practice guidelines as treating the setting as part of the intervention. “Setting is literally part of the treatment,” he said during the session. “You are looking at the interaction between behavior and environment. It’s just baked in.”
He traced the legal version of that idea to Burke v. Independence Blue Cross, a 2017 decision in which the Pennsylvania Supreme Court ruled 4 to 1 that an insurer could not use a place-of-service exclusion to deny coverage for ABA delivered at school under the state’s autism mandate. The majority called ABA “an environmentally sensitive form of therapy.” The family’s attorney, Unumb said, got the court to see that “you can’t separate setting and environment from the treatment.” In Philadelphia, Medicaid ABA now runs partly through a provider network built around school-based clusters.
State mandates don’t reach self-funded employer plans, and for those, Unumb said, the argument runs through federal mental health parity law. Plans tend to respond that they don’t pay for medical care at school either. His reply is that a setting exclusion removes a core component of the treatment. “You don’t say, ‘Yeah, I’ll cover your cancer, but I’m not going to do chemo,’” he said.
The ADA Route to ABA in Public Schools
Under the ADA, Unumb said, a child who medically needs a therapist at school can ask for one as an accommodation, so that the child can access the school “to the same extent as possible as someone who is not disabled.” The comparison he reached for was a dog.
In Fry v. Napoleon Community Schools, decided in 2017, the U.S. Supreme Court heard the case of a Michigan kindergartner with cerebral palsy whose school would not let her bring her service dog, Wonder. The Court held that families must first exhaust the appeals process under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) only when the core of their lawsuit is the denial of a free appropriate public education.
A special education attorney Unumb worked with took to calling the ABA therapist “Wonder Dog.” Unumb put the decision more plainly. “Your legal rights don’t stop at the schoolhouse door.”
The difference is partly procedural. A disability discrimination claim that clears the Fry test can go straight to federal court. “Schools are really good at IDEA stuff. They’re really good at due process,” Unumb said. “They know how to kind of drag that process on, but they are not good at all of a sudden finding themselves in federal court with the preliminary injunction scheduled two weeks from now.”
In Perez v. Sturgis Public Schools in 2023, a unanimous Supreme Court held that IDEA exhaustion does not bar an ADA lawsuit seeking compensatory damages, a remedy the IDEA cannot provide. “This opens up a whole lot of potential remedies,” Unumb said.
The route is not equally open everywhere. In Derek S. v. Ballston Spa Central School District, the Second Circuit held in a December 2025 summary order that a family’s ADA and Section 504 claims seeking ABA at school were claims for educational services, subject to IDEA exhaustion. The family’s petition to the Supreme Court argued that the Fourth and Ninth Circuits had reached the opposite result on similar claims. The Court denied review on May 18, 2026.
Inside the Kansas ABA Injunction
The district’s objections, as the court summarized them, were practical. Its insurer would not cover people the district did not employ and wanted indemnity agreements. Administrators raised the difficulty of supervising outside staff, along with risks to classroom security and privacy, and they worried about precedent in a district where, by its own count, roughly 1,000 students receive accommodations. The district offered a memorandum of understanding that would have required $5 million in liability and workers’ compensation insurance from Ad Astra and kept the therapists out of classrooms. Ad Astra declined.
Powell was not persuaded. “The District’s claims strike the Court as speculative and not supported by caselaw,” he wrote. He acknowledged that the district “is rightly concerned with the privacy and security of other students in the classroom,” but found the hardships it described unconvincing because “they are speculative, unsupported, or were previously tolerated by the District.” The same therapists, he noted, had already spent a year in those classrooms. “Meaningful access to education requires being able to attend in a substantive sense with an equal opportunity to participate,” he wrote.
The order puts an amended memorandum of understanding in place. Ad Astra’s therapists may serve the two girls in their classrooms, the agreement can be ended only for cause with 30 days to cure, and background checks and confidentiality agreements are limited to what the district required before Policy KM. Providers must carry liability coverage “at the current industry standard of $1,000,000.” The injunction does not require the district to pay for the therapists, and Powell waived the bond requirement. The case remains open, and the docket shows the families filed an amended complaint on Nov. 12.
State Laws on ABA in Schools Set the Ground Rules
Unumb has been drafting legislation in several states. The model, he said, “recognizes this is an ADA issue” and “puts out kind of a framework and ground rules” for handling a family’s request.
South Carolina’s Act 186, signed May 18, is the most detailed so far. It names ABA therapy, covers Board Certified Behavior Analysts and Registered Behavior Technicians, and requires that the services be authorized by a third-party payer such as Medicaid, a commercial insurer, or a self-funded plan. Districts must weigh each request case by case under the ADA and may deny one that would impose an undue burden or a fundamental alteration, but they may not use an IEP decision under the IDEA to deny or limit ADA-based services. The State Board of Education must finalize a model policy by Jan. 6, 2027, and districts must adopt their own policies by July 1, 2027.
Tennessee enacted its own law this year, Chapter 1112 of the Public Acts of 2026. In July, the state Department of Education issued implementation guidance that calls for a written parent request and a memorandum of understanding with each provider, bars private providers from using restraint or isolation on school property, and gives parents, though not providers, a local appeal. Colorado, under a 2022 law, has required districts since 2023 to adopt written policies on medically necessary treatment at school and, since 2024, to report how many requests from private specialists they approve and deny.
Other efforts are still moving. Michigan’s House Bill 5044, which would require districts to adopt policies letting students receive medically necessary treatment at school, cleared the House education committee with a substitute in June and awaits a floor vote. Kansas’s SB 441 would have shielded districts from liability for a private provider’s actions; it cleared the Senate Education Committee in March but went no further, and Unumb said advocates will bring it back. In Massachusetts, H.4927 sits with the Joint Committee on Education.
Even explicit state policy can run into local control. Joy Pollard, CASP’s Vice President of Clinical Standards, said during the session that in New Mexico, where she did most of her clinical work, “schools have local control and they can allow services to be provided or not.”
From ABA School Access Laws to District Policy
South Carolina’s school access law is six months old, and families are already testing it. One attendee who hears from parents said during the session that neighboring districts are reading the law differently. Unumb said he and colleagues had talked the night before about assembling explanations and template letters for parents.
“Once you get a statute passed, that is the starting point, but that is by no means the ending point,” he said. “A lot of it’s going to occur during this implementation phase.”
The win in Kansas is also a narrow one. Powell’s order reaches two students and their therapists. It does not strike down Policy KM, and the case has not gone to trial. The district told the court it provides accommodations to about 1,000 students.




